If it walks like a snake and talks like a snake . . .
Hey, everyone! Lincee is on vacation this week and needed someone to fill in for her so she asked me and her friend Jill to write this week’s recap. Jill (not to be confused with Jillian) told Lincee that she wouldn’t write but she would come watch the show with me and help me out. I think she also secretly told Lincee that if our recap was a big, boring flop she wanted it to be on my shoulders alone. Thanks, Jill.
So let me introduce myself . . . my name is Catherine. I’m 33, a Libra, and have an unnatural love of Swiss Cake Rolls. Nice to meet you.
Lincee told us that she usually does a top 10 for The Men Tell All episode so Jill and I sat down with our laptops and got ready to make notes of our favorite moments from the show. Surely there would be lots of excitement, right? In the end, it was a bit of a bore. I had to keep rewinding things for Jill because she kept getting more interested in a craft blog she was reading. Seriously – who reads craft blogs?? But I digress . . .
We had a hard time picking our top 10 things from the episode. Should we write about how presh Michael is and how he makes me want to learn to break dance for the first time in my life? Or should we write about how edgy ROBBY D!!! was in this episode? Or how awkward the Reid hula dancing scene was? Or how Jake really can’t pull off the F-bomb? So many things to choose from! So we decided that, instead of just 10 our Favorites, we’d give you a Baker’s Dozen. You’re welcome.
So here we go . . .
13. I love how Gary the camera guy gets random, awkward shots of women in the audience who look at each other “spontaneously” to react to something scandalous that was just said. You can almost hear Gary cueing them: “Give me disgusted. Nice. Now give me surprised. Good job, ladies. Now turn to each other and mumble. You ladies are naturals.”
12. There were LOTS of cuss words tonight, weren’t there? Gene the Bleep Guy FINALLY got the action he’s been waiting for. (Psssst . . . Lincee, I hope you don’t mind but I created an ABC guy and named him Gene. Also, I hope you don’t mind that I have decided that Gene and Gary the Camera Guy are best buds and play poker every other Thursday night. Let’s talk about it when you get home.)
11. I was reminded of how much Sasha confuses me every time he speaks. He tries but he has a hard time making sense. And he talks SOOOOO fast, you find yourself concentrating more on the fact that he hasn’t taken a breath. It’s kind of amazing, really: “Whenyoutellpeopleallthetimethatyou’reperfectthatwomenwantsomethingtofixthat’snottrue. Theywantittybittygreenswimmingshorts.Andthenwhenyoucomeacrossit’ssocannedlike itcameoffoflikeasoapoperait’slikethewholenineyards.Likeamythicalunicorn.You’reasheepandI’mawolf.Haveyouseentheunicorn? Andthat’swhyjillianwaslikebeyourselfandyou’relikethisiswhoIambutitdoesn’tlooklikearealperson, itlookslikea*****actor.” [Aaaaaaaaaaaaaand gasp for breath]. I just find myself saying “huh?” every time he opens his mouth.
10. Pizza Guy Mark made a late break for some airtime in this episode. I mean, he’s a few roses too late but I appreciate the effort – he spoke up LOTS. We found out he has an opinion. We found out he has a sense of humor. We found out he has a shirt that says “US.” And we got to see him in a playful snowball fight with Jillian. Where was THAT footage before he got eliminated? Poor guy got ripped off. He should have talked about being there to promote his pizza . . .
And can I take a second to go back to the snow ball fight for a sec? Jillian says “Mark LITERALLY knocked me on my ass with a snowball.” That’s a flagrant misuse of the word “literally” and I can’t let it go. I rewound it several times, Jilly, and your feet never left the ground. When people misuse that word, it LITERALLY makes my ears bleed.
But I digress . . .
9. How can we not talk about the awkward cameo of Jason and Molly? It was uncomfortable for me. I wanted to give them a courtesy laugh just to make the silence more bearable in my living room. When Jason referred to them as the “M&M team” and got no reaction, my butt clenched. LITERALLY. Jill gagged and then said the WORD “Gag” and then we were treated to the video montage of the lovely couple while also having to watch them watch THEMSELVES in the little picture in picture inset. This is when Jill began convulsing. My favorite part of the video, though, was the end where Molly is laying with her head on Jason’s lap and he bends down to kiss her. My L-5 ruptured just watching it.
8. Daaaaaaaaaaaaavid, David, David . . . what the hell is wrong with you?? Is it possible that you are seriously that boorish?? Are you really that confused that a women doesn’t swoon when you compliment her “ass”? Is this the first time that line hasn’t worked for you? His look of confusion just made me dislike him more. And, speaking of looks . . . did you catch Juan’s look when Our Host Chris Harrison asked David what he thought about Juan? Priceless. But my favorite part of the whole David-on-the-hotseat portion of the night was when OHCH asked Mike, Tanner P. and Jake what they thought of David’s disrespect of Jillian. You could see the blood drain from their faces as they gulped nervously, tried to answer, and then were ushered away by Witness Protection.
7. Let’s talk about Jake. Now, IHGB readers, please don’t judge me but I must admit to y’all that I am JUST NOW seeing that Jake might be a bit of a dork. I can’t really bring myself to say it out loud yet but it’s slowly dawning on me. BUT I can’t help but like Jake. I think he seems like a nice guy with a good heart and a streak of dork that he just can’t hide. And, really, how can he when he puts so much shoulder into his laugh? It’s a dead giveaway. Bless his heart.
6. And speaking of Jake, did you catch it when that one audience member stood up to encourage Jake in his decision to expose Wes and then she said “You were being a good man, a good friend.” Poor Jake’s face falls at the word “friend.” I said “Poor guy” and I actually heard Jill’s eyes roll into the back of her head.
5. Drunk Ed. Enough said.
4. I loved it when OHCH randomly picks a guy out of the audience to get a “dude’s” perspective because “let’s face it – these guys aren’t helping men out.” Nice, Chris Harrison. Well done. The guys in the audience suddenly put their heads down, start squirming in their seats, and silently beg God to spare them this humiliation on national TV. OHCH picks a token dude to talk to and the look on that guy’s face is priceless. It was a combination of “Oh crap – poker night’s gonna be awkward this week.” and “Something tells me this is the mother of all Man Code violations.” Poor guy.
3. “If it walks like a snake and talks like a snake, chances are it’s not the kind of guy that most women would want to date.” Awesome. This succinct and catchy phrase will catch on. Like “cheese ass.”
2. The blooper reel. I’m a sucker for blooper reels, folks. When it became apparent that that’s what we were watching, I leaned forward with a big open-mouthed grin on my face and got ready for entertainment. I wasn’t disappointed. Tanner F. dodging a bee in his western wear, Jillian pulling OHCH’s finger, Michael’s . . . ummmmm . . . gas following him, and a possibly drunk Jillian in ecstacy over a piece of pepperoni pizza. I’m quite sure that last part left Pizza Guy Mark thinking Jillian might have been his soulmate and left Tanner P. fantasizing about her eating pizza with her toes. As for me, I made a mental note to give pepperoni pizza another shot.
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaand the best thing about tonight . . .
1. Our Host Chris Harrison finally got some airtime!!! And he is FUNNY!!!! Jill spent a lot of time talking about how much she loves him and I, too, found myself drawn in by his hosting prowess. He’s super presh. And he was calling people out left and right. That would normally make my butt clench, but OHCH has a talent for clench-free confrontation. I loved it when he called the guys out for making a big deal about Juan doing a shot. I agree, Chris Harrison . . . “who gives a crap?” And I loved it when he asked David “when you say ‘I want him to go drown himself’ that means I wanna hug it out?” We rewound that one a couple of times. But our favorite line from him tonight was “so you’re saying ‘Love Don’t Come Easy’ isn’t original??” That’s good stuff, people. Good stuff.
So that’s it, folks! And now we have the finale and Lincee’s return to blogging to look forward to. Is Jillian in love? Is she engaged? Or is she just “extremely happy?”
We’ll see!!!!







awww, they seem genuinely happy !
I was wondering that, too, Mallory (as far as the song goes)
cmon, she squeals, she straddles, she’s happy, be happy for her
Oh, I am happy for them!
Aw, Ed is a cutie! He seems to really love Jill, and they are both so corny. But it’s sweet. I am sure there are lots of girls awaiting Reid’s return. He was a sweetie. I think everyone will have a happy ending – for the meantime.
i am happy for them… they are cute.
You know what’s awesome? At the end of the show, you get a really nice music video. That would be cool to have done professionally over the entire term of my romance, what’s this, like 8 weeks? Anyway, if someone would have just followed my husband and me around for the 2 months we dated before he and I decided to get married, I could have beautiful, romantic videos of my courtship. Yes, I said two months
practically a lifetime in Bachelorette years.
That, and I loved Ed and his ugly shorts. Any wagers to see how long this will actually last?
Yay! Love is grand!
Until tomorrow night when we find out they’ve broken up already.
#338 All about the shame- except for her usage of “undescribable”…! In, Jillian! Indescribable!
So Kiptyn or Reid as the next Bachelor??
Neither
I’m happy for her if she’s happy. That ring though… yeah wouldn’t be my choice! lol Yeah hon first matter of business…we need to change this! lol
#348 Lorac – HILARIOUS! I didn’t take it that way but I love your spin on it! LMAO!
The taping at the end seemed less scripted and less forced, so we’ll see. I still heart Reid and DO NOT WANT HIM OR KIP TO BE THE NEXT BACHELOR! New blood or no blood at all darn it!
Even though Kip got his heartbroken…I love all the ab action I got to see one last time!
Oh wait…is that shallow? OH WELL..TOOOOOOO BAD! LOL
Oh I wanted to comment about the confession bit, I said it on a comments page way back when, but it was the same sound bit that Ed said when he left the first time, and I just think they were throwing stuff in there to throw us off. There never was a confession other than Reid coming back and telling her he loved her. You see they didn’t even show him standing w/ the ring by himself like they did in the preview.
Saggleo….she did say “undescribable” because the closed captioning was on because we lost sound on ABC for the last 45 minutes on and off in Kansas City. Thanks ABC, I have put a solid 30 hours of TV watching and blog reading to not have sound during the finale.
So happy for Jilly and Ed
you said it, c list….poor reid. I fast-forwarded through everything but that part. stupid canadians.
#366 – Think I’m lost Jen. I don’t think I commented on the undescribable thing so you may mean this for someone else.
I was talking about the confession voice over they played in the previews last week, of Ed saying it’s going to hurt her or whatever, and saying it was from when he left.
#284…. I’ve been trying to find a way to describe his OBNOXIOUS touch problem and I laughed out loud when I read “meaningful touching”…. that’s exactly what he is doing (or trying to do?). He always caressing her and it looks SO uncomfortable. Kind of like the first time your 14 year old boyfriend tried to be cute and romantic. It’s just so awkward. I guess I am just too much of a Reid fan to let go…
I will say, after this evening, I wouldn’t mind seeing Kip as the next Bachelor
Saggleo – whoops, I meant #359 – sc
Team Reid- can’t believe she let him go again- big mistake huge…
Ed is so much taller than Jillian and I’m thinking she liked that because he could really swoop her up and let her straddle him.
Poor Reid!
I wish they would have a Bachelor season with lots and lots of really smart, successful women and he could find true love.
Jillian really grew on me and I have to say I admire her for not trying to be someone she is not–she and Ed will probably make a really nice couple. The other two guys might have been a little too perfect, but who knows!?
Ok…. I love Reid, I really do, but too little too late. You can’t show up at the last possible moment and expect a fairy tale… life (unfortunately) does not work that way. I think Jillian was right, had he said that the feelings were there and decided not to act like he was 4 (his words not mine) things might have been different. Reid will make out just fine! Both he and Kip will be scooped up and will have their own happily ever after (either that or they can be next seasons Bachelors… there’s a twist… two bachelors
).
All in all great season, lots of ups and downs… she definitely slayed a dragon or two and ended up with three fantastic guys. I hope that things work out. Can’t hate her for following her heart!
J + E = <3
Hey Jen #366….I’m in KC and I flipped out when the sound went out…I had to call a friend in Boston to give me the play by play…I’m glad she didn’t pick Reid…he’s too good for her and he’s going to be just fine!
Oh,,,, #363… totally agree about the abs! Hubba Hubba!
I have to put my two cents in: THIS IS THE WORST ACTING I’VE SEEN SINCE “THE HILLS”… did anyone else notice that our boy Ed was wearing the exact same outfit in the scene where he “said goodbye to Jill” and the one that he “returned bc he decided his job wasn’t as important as finding true love”???? Yeah… white collared shirt, navy sweater… you can’t tell me that ABC didn’t orchestrate Ed’s leaving along with Reid’s “shocking return”. First of all, she didn’t do a good job of acting genuinely surprised about either one of the above events. Second, ABC is growing desperate for ratings after seasons of failed relationships and a loss of interest from their fan base. They found a handful of puppets that were willing to play the role that was allocated to them in return for their 15 minutes. I will be honest: I’m a Reid fan. He won me over. Hundred bucks says my man Reid is the next Bachelor… I’m just sayin.
Yeah Team Ed! I would MUCH rather have Kiptyn than egomaniac Jake as the next bachelor, Maybe they should stop the recycling and find someone new. Or is the audience small enough that they have to pick someone fans like. If so, bring on the break-dancing brothers and make it a twin thing. All I have to say if it is the personally appointed perfect Jake – I will not watch. I can’t commit to not reading Lincee’s blog though.
I do hope Ed & Polly last though. It’d be another point that gals pick better than guys.
#376 – Really? Hmmmm…how far do I have to rewind to catch this? Was it in the final montage of Ed and Jillian or way before?
#378- it was in the beginning…first half hour. Before he meets the parents, I think.
ok, the fact that she even THOUGHT about accepting Reid’s proposal says she’s not ready to be engaged! Did you see her wiggle her ring finger when Reid proposed? Poor girl’s just itching for that ring (no matter who it’s from). And Ed, dude, that’s an U-G-L-Y $60K ring, my friend.
I’m watching the ending now, but really, does she actually jump on him while wearing the dress?!? Oh my God, I am so happy her season is over!!
I know I am late…but, I have to tell ya’ll that my satellite went out right as Kippy was chosing the ring and I did NOT know because I was watching it in play back mode! The taping froze I was in the house (luckily, by myself) screaming at the satellite, saying DO YOU NOT KNOW THIS IS THE FINALE!!!! WHAT’S WRONG WITH YOU!!! Luckily, the receiver downstairs was working just fine and I saw the ceremony.
I agree (and I’m an any gem girl) that Ed’s ring was BUTT UGLY!!! My sister came home right as Ed pulled up and sat through his portion and said it reminded her of the ugly first ring Aidan gave Carrie on Sex & the City with the exception that it not JUST a diamond with a gold band.
Jilli seems to like and I told my sis that she was from way way way northern Canada and she might actually like that monstrosity!
I did not know you guys blogged during the show. Will definitely have be on line 2morrow nite for ATFR! I want to be included!!!
I don’t want eithe Kippy or Reid as the next bachelor. Can we get fresh faces with a group of non-bimbo-ey girls who don’t flip their hair like “Deb” on Drop Dead Diva!
i’m just saying…
OMG. I can’t believe she chose that Bassett Hound over Reid. I think Reid lost her when he got down on one knee, but only said that she was someone he could “see” himself spending the rest of his life with. He never came right out and asked her. I think she was looking for the sure thing. I wouldn’t mind seeing either Reid or Kiptyn as the next bachelor. I think Kip will be more passionate when he does the picking, and you just know the girls (oops, women) will be climbing all over each other fighting for him.
The name should only be KoKo…haven’t blogged from this laptop this season. And it is late.
going to entertainment weekly to see what OHCH says…hoepfully it is posted by now.
Really? – I rewound. Okay it’s before they pick the rings. I don’t think it’s the same outfit. When he left it was a solid navy sweater w/ a shirt…when he came back it was argyle. I’d have to go online to search for the leaving episode, but unless they just put on another sweater…I’m not sure how much I will buy into that theory but it is an interesting one. But the outfit isn’t the same. In the clip of Ed they show, they only show the back of him not the front…and I remember it being argyle in the return.
#383 KoKo OHCH Tweeted his blog won’t be up ’til Wed. wanted to save it until after the ATFR episode.
I heart Reid – but hope all are happy!
It really seemed to me that Jill’s family liked Kip bettter, except for Dad. I liked Kip better! I kept thinking – pick Kip, pick Kip!
This show is so mean. The poor guys are left thinking – she was so happy to see me, she jumped into my arms, she must love me. Sorry, I fell in love with someone else. I think she should date them after for a month and find out what is really there!
All she has had is problems with Ed. So I hope she is happy and in love.
#369 and #284: Yes, Ed’s touching problem would drive me CRAZY! I kept wanting to slap his hands away from her when they were sitting at the table talking. His fingers are on her cheek…now pulling back a stray hair…now stroking her ear…now back to the cheek. Ick, Ick, Ick! Exactly like a 14-year-old boy trying to act romantic. If you just HAVE to touch her, hold her hands or something, Ed! Sheesh!
I hope he doesn’t act like a touchy tom now that they’re engaged because it is sure to make everyone around them uncomfortable! It makes me think he doesn’t have much expereince with women (although Jill seemed to dig it).
i love love love that reid was wearing a suit and tennis shoes :0) i want him
Stop hating on Ed. I think he is adorable and funny and sarcastic and a total nerd. I think he fits in great with Jillian. He was not wearing the same outfit when he left and came back – go back and watch one is a plain sweater and the other is a cute argoyle sweater. She really seems to have fallen in love with him and I knew from the way she acted when he left that there was more than we ever saw. Reid was precious and I felt sorry for him but I believe her reaction was because she didn’t want to hurt him. Regardless of the ring (not my style but neither are alot of rings I see people wearing!), I hope they are happy and I am excited for the After the Rose! Now, I will go read OHCH and Jillian’s blog before I get my Lincee fix!
I heart Reid!!!
Me too!