This…is American Idol

Sunday, March 21, 2010 @ 09:03 PM
Author: Lincee

Da na da na da na….whhhhaaaaa whhhhaaaaaaa.

That was totally the song intro.

Hello people. It’s that time again in which American Idol Guest Blogger Kyle and I go head-to-head on our love for Crystal Bowersox and irritation for all things Kara. (Raise your hand if you miss Paula and her gin-soaked QVC jewelry!)

Kyle was nice enough to break down our Top 12. This goes out to all you closet Idolholics out there. LET YOUR VOICE BE HEARD IN THE COMMENT SECTION!

Lincee out.

* * *
Ever since sweet Ryan announced Kris Allen was the winner last year, I have been waiting for this season. There is just something about this show that I love. I mean I love good music, and then when they throw in all of the heartwarming stories, well let’s just say I am hooked. The problem with this year is that there is just not the talent level so far as compared to the past few years. Usually, at this time, there are the four or five that stand out, and you can not wait for them to sing. That is just not happening this year. There are some good ones, but no where the same as the last few times.

SIDEBAR
I told Lincee I was going to do this. She has final say if this stays in or not, so there is a chance this will not be posted. If you all did not watch The Sing Off this past December, I just feel sorry for you. It was one of the best shows I have ever seen. As we are watching it, you realize that there is just pure, raw talent in these groups. The sure sign for me if I like something is if I will buy the song. I ended up buying 16 songs from the show, and still waiting for more to come available. So my shameless plug is coming to a close. In conclusion, WATCH THE SHOW WHEN IT RETURNS TO NBC. I put it in caps so you know I was serious.

So with the top 12, there a few favorites I have. I will mentions them later, but here are a few things I have noticed this year so far:

Kara is a human fortune cookie. It is like right before she talks, she cracks open one of the sweet, advice giving pieces of goodness and reads from them.

Kara: “Michael, when life comes at you, and things are tough, lean on friends to get you through. Look into the looking glass of your mind to find the voice you are looking for, and from that a flower will spring up to birth new life to a whole new road that you will be willing to take. If you find yourself backed into a corner, look deep in the eyes of your enemy and find the songs that makes them melt, and take a hold of that and run with it. Oh, I liked the song.”

I have determined who she is. For college basketball fans, she is Bill Raftery. Like Bill, Kara has become a cartoon character of herself. I really could see her on one of those random Cartoon Network shows that over dramatize everything. But with her, I think they would nail it right on the head.

I loved when Simon called Kara out. When Kara said that they were not connecting with the song, and Simon said it was rubbish. I loved that because it is so true. They didn’t write the songs. They have no idea what to do. Just let them up and sing. When a 16 year old boy is singing about his wife and kids, of course he is not going to connect on an emotional level with that. But you know what? I bet he could sing his face off and make it sound really good. Kara, I know you wrote 573 songs and you can connect anywhere from a single girl crying for her blanket, to a unicorn who has lost his way and looking for home. But not everyone can.

MICHAEL LYNCHE
If you asked the Incredible Hulk to play guitar, it would actually look bigger in his hands that the one Michael holds. I love when he plays guitar, because I always ask myself, “Is he playing a ukelele.” I like that he didn’t play the guitar this time. I think it shows versatility and also they can not hide behind something. It forces them to get outside of their comfort zones. I love watching him dance, the problem is that he only has about three moves, and that’s it. And they all involve his hands. If he had others dancing on the stage with him, I have no doubt in my mind that one swoop of his big mitts, and one of those frilly haired party girls are going flat on their face.

I like Mike. He has an incredible voice and he uses it very well. You just have to get past the fact that he is a giant and should be ripping peoples heads off, but instead he is singing sweet melodies. I feel he will go far.

DIDI BENAMI
I did not think contestants could come back on if the made the top 12. I guess this year they are making an exception. I am excited they let Brooke White back on the show. I hope she sings Let it Be again on the piano. I will for sure shed a tear.

I like DiDi. Other than being gorgeous, she really has a great voice. She has not done much over the past weeks, but this week came out of her shell and really let people know how well she can sing. I loved watching it and it was for sure one of my favorites of the night. If I know the song, I would have liked it a lot better. She hit some high notes that I really thought were awesome. The judges like her and thought she had potential. I think she will be a girl who goes far.

I HAVE AT&T U-VERSE, WHICH IF YOU DON’T HAVE IT, YOU NEED TO DROP WHATEVER CABLE COMPANY AND GET THIS ONE. IT IS FANTASTIC. I HAVE FOUND ONE PROBLEM WITH IT. THEY HAVE THIS 30 SECOND FAST FORWARD BUTTON, THAT IS USED TO GO THROUGH COMMERCIALS. I AM PROPOSING THEM A KARA FAST FORWARD BUTTON. SO LET’S SHE SHE STARTS TALKING, ALL YOU WOULD HAVE TO DO IS PUSH THIS BUTTON, AND IT WOULD AUTOMATICALLY SKIP HER AND STOP RIGHT ON SIMON. PRETTY SURE I WOULD BE A MILLIONAIRE.

CASEY JAMES
Whenever Kara is not molesting him with her eyes, he actually is not a bad singer. Randy compared him to a Stevie Ray Vaughn, and I thought that was a great idea. He is not great, he hides behind his guitar (a lot of them do this year) and doesn’t sing flashy. But he can sing and could be entertaining.

LACEY BROWN
Poor girl. She has a good voice, but only for about 10 songs. She sounds like they lead singer from Sixpence None the Richer. Also, if you listen, she sounds like a not very good version of Stevie Nicks. Judges thought it was a weird performance. Vocally good, just not great.

ANDREW GARCIA
He sang Gimme Shelter. They best cover of this, EVER was by the Clark Brothers on Next Great American Band. If you have not watched this, go to YouTube right now. It is amazing. I like that he did not have a guitar. I think that was very brave of him and tried something else. It was a very unique version of the song. I watched it again and thought it was good. I think he is in trouble because he will always be compared to Straight Up, and not sure he can get away from that.

KATIE STEVENS
They keep telling her to be young. How in the world are you able to be young with the Rolling Stones? You know what? Let’s not worry about her age. Just let her sing and then judge her voice. That should be easy enough. That is what this show is, right?

TIM URBAN
Not a whole lot to say. He is trying to be Jason Castro. I would love to see him play without the guitar. See what he looks like on that stage. Middle to end of the pack.

SIOBHAN MAGNUS
I hate haunted houses. When I was little, we used to go to Bells amusement Park in Tulsa, OK and my family always wanted to take me on the haunted house ride. I went once and I think I soiled myself, and have not been on since. When I watched this performance, I had the same feeling. I was actually scared and had to go in to the other room and peek around the corner. All I could think was the female version of Adam.

Scary performances that make you just stare confused, and you have that look on your face, wondering what you are watching.
She screams. Just a lot longer than Adam did. Like when you think, “Ok, she is winding down,” she is actually just getting going.
She has given whatever punch Adam gave to the judges last year, this year to drink. Because they drank it and are all about the Magnus express.

The good thing about her is that her name is for sure some sort of superhero name.

LEE DEWYZE
For sure my favorite guy, no question. I love his voice and talent. He, along with Crystal, make singing look so easy. They just get up there, put out no effort, and blow the song away. The bad thing is that he will get sucked into the Daughtry, Nickelback, Shinedown parade, which is a never ending pit of bad music despair. Please Lee, don’t do it.

Really, he is my favorite because in his video he had a TMNT shirt on when he was younger. If that doesn’t scream winner, nothing does. I called him my favorite at the beginning of the top 24. Hope I am right.

PAIGE MILES & AARON KELLY
I have them together, because they remind me of the same. They have good voices, young and cute and fun to watch. I like them and hope they do good. The problem is, in a couple of weeks they will run smack into a wall and the pressure will crush them. They are great now, but are middle of the pack.

CRYSTAL BOWERSOX
Great voice. She is fun to watch and I hope she does good. It is always fun to watch her face when being judged, because if you had the sound off and based what they said on her reactions, you would be wrong 100 percent of the time. It is kind of funny. I think the judges don’t like that, because they want emotion and people to fight back, and she ain’t doing that. They were harsh on her, which was dumb, because she was great. I think they are trying to level the playing field a little bit.

If I had to pick my bracket for this show, here is what it would be (now I know this will be WAY WAY WAY WAY off.)

12. Lacey
11. Paige Miles
10. Tim Urban
9. Katie Stevens
8. Aaron Kelly
7. Casey James
6. Andrew Garcia
5. Michael Lynche
4. Didi Benami
3. Siobhan Magnus
2. Crystal Bowersox
1. Lee Dewyze

Not what I want, but what I think will happen. Again, going to be way off. Happy watching everybody. I hope you tune back in to the blog and read what we write. These are just my opinions, if you want to argue, bring it, I love a good battle.

Thanks for reading.

20 Responses to “This…is American Idol”

  1. Stacy says:

    Back to the whole Cord McCoy thing – have you heard about his nearly life ending injury? http://www.cordmccoy.com – there are pics on the side you can view. Think it was in 2004.

  2. Leslie from Austin says:

    I miss Adam!!!!!

  3. Leslie from Austin says:

    I miss Adam!!!!!!!!!

  4. Idoleedwyze says:

    Thanks Kyle – hope that this week your blog can come out before the results show airs so we can see if you are right or wrong? Not sure if you were saying that 1,2,3 were the bottom 3 or what but if you were, you were right. I will just assume you are a Idol genius and picked it absolutely correct!

    I love Lee and Crystal and Didi. I could stare into Lee’s blue eyes all night long and listen to his voice forever. I think he sounds more like the lead singer of Counting Crows – he has that vibe to him.

    I like Crystal but she needs to get excited up this mother – show some emotion of the young kiddies will send her home!

    Tell next time and thanks Lincee for bringing Kyle back.

    P.S. Was the Sing-off the Accapella show? If so, I loved it as well…if not, please elaborate!

  5. MarriedWithEyes says:

    Why can’t we see what others are saying above?

    I disagree in that I think this group is as talented as most other seasons have been. I just think that they are pimping the stories just a bit too much this year. I would almost feel guilty not to give Big Mike and his baby a vote or two. He has been great vocally the last few weeks but before that I didn’t know why he was there. I feel the same about Katie – feel like I’m voting for her granny. On the flip side I think Crystal is a great singer but I don’t care really if she is eliminated for some reason – not bonded. I think there are a few artists that could make it with this boost. I love Lee and Didi and even Siobhan (although I wasn’t gaga for Adam Lambert) but not sure I could take a whole album of her.
    LOVE DAUGHTRY’s music though.
    Glad to see this post – you did a great job Kyle and for the most part I agree!

  6. Randee says:

    Just had to comment about “Sing Off”…………TOTALLY agree!!! It needs to be on again ASAP!! It was so incredible–such talent!

  7. heidi says:

    I’m so not feeling the talent or personalities of 93% of the contestants on Idol. The only ones I feel I can get behind are Bowersox and Dewyze.

  8. Julie says:

    Ok — the only person I know in American Idol Is Andrew Garcia because of the “straight up” cover… it was good — and I honestly feel like this show isn’t worth watching this season. Just an opinion.

    BUT: I’m sooo glad that Lincee left the sidenote BECAUSE I LOVED “THE SING OFF”. I felt that there was true talent and I loved loved loved Nota (the winners). I actually was watching their performance again in You Tube last nite!!! Can’t wait for it to come back!! :)

  9. LJ2B says:

    I’ve enjoyed A.I. so far, but agree it isn’t as good as past seasons thus far.

    In general, I like the theme weeks…but prefer when it is a bit broader in nature to give contestants a bigger pool of songs to choose from. I like the Rolling Stones, but felt that many of the songs selected didn’t resonate well with the viewers. The younger audience (and contestants) never even heard most of those songs before…which tends to make them less interested in the show that week.

    And I agree that is difficult for some contestants like Katie to deliver what the judges are asking of her. They want her to sing modern, upbeat, youthful songs…but then she is limited to the Rolling Catalog for her song selection. That’s a disconnect.

  10. kyle says:

    Thanks for commenting.

    Leslie, I know you miss Adam, but I promise if you turn the radio on his song is on it now. And they brought in Siobhan, so that is pretty much Adam for you right there.

    It was my fault the blog did not come out, I will get it to Lincee earlier. I already put my predictions on now, so I can’t hide behind it anymore. Ha.

    And for those of you that like the Sing Off, it is my new addiction. I can talk about that for years and years and years. Every time someone comes to my house, I make them watch my favorite performances. Trust me, if you would like to discuss, that is a whole nother topic. Just ask Lincee, I have made her ears bleed with my talk about it.

    You all are awesome.

  11. Holly says:

    I completely agree with everything you said about The Sing Off.
    Oh, and Kara is scaring me…make it stop.

  12. carol in CA says:

    I so agree you Green Beaners, “Sing Off” was the bomb !!!!

  13. saggleo says:

    Not an Idol watcher…since long long seasons ago. But the Sing Off…WAS FREAKING AWESOME!! I felt like almost everytime I caught it my jaw would be on the floor in amazement!

  14. Michelle b says:

    Lee Dewyze Lee Dewyze….im well into my 30′s and i feel like a teenie bopper when he comes on stage. I love love love his voice. He will get lopped in with the daughtry’s of the world but he is way more talented. However, i do think simon is a bit right with him in Re: to his personality. He needs to let loose and im sure people will fall in love. He is very much like david cook for me, i liked him, but when he let loose, he was on a different level than anyone else.

  15. OKJen says:

    Just had to say I LOVED the reference to Bells!! I’m from Muskogee and went there often for field trips, family and church outings and birthday parties. I hated the haunted house and the old rickety (sp?) white roller coaster. That thing was a danger..I’m sure of it!! Not that into Idol this season either and I agree there aren’t as many stand-outs as in the past seasons. I do love Bowersox and hope she is in the top two. My husband is a fan of Deweze…we’ll see who’s right! Great blog post!

  16. MJ says:

    Great job once again Kyle. I loved the Bill Raftery reference, I think another similarity between Bill and Kara is how they just say things to hear themselves talk. “Take it to the tin!!” I think you also hit the nail on the head as far as the judges trying to “level the playing field” by the way they are so harsh on Crystal. In my humble opinion she is head and shoulders above the competition and has been consistently good.
    Look forward to more great posts.

  17. will says:

    JAIME FOX NEEDS TO BE ONE OF THE JUDGES. I love Ellen on HER show but not as a judge. She isn’t funny, doesn’t look like she is having fun and doesn’t know anything about music. Randy no longer adds anything (he says yo and dog a lot and I love it/hate it and that is it)
    The talent isn’t that great this year either. Really? These are the best of the best?
    Big Mike: too much. A bit too dancy dance/cheese at times. I just keep thinking of his little legs going side to side when he’s dancing.

    16 yr old: Great voice but would you really pay to see him at a concert? He’s so young..seems like state fair/brainard act.

    Greg brady: Don’t know his name. Think his last name is Urban? He reminds me of Greg Brady is all I know.
    Shibaun Shivan: no idea on her name but I can’t watch her. Pretty sure she has a mary poppins tattoo (random) and she needs a stylist. There is unique style…and then just weirdness pulled from the closet. I think her parents smoked pot. just sayin’
    and the scream? They seem impressed so it must sound good in person but i hate it. can i use the word hate? b/c that is how strongly i feel. it sounds horrible to me- it is NOT singing.

    Casey is good although he said he realized he needs to work the stage. What I don’t get though…is that he said that…but managed the next song (the power of love) to stand in one spot behind his guitar.

    Andrew garcia: such a cool voice. CAN they PLEASE stop talking about straight up for the love! Yes, that was amazing and pulled up youtube to listen to it again but come up with some new comments!!!

    Lee: awesome voice. I love the story that he worked at a paint store. What a cool life- paint to performing! I hope he goes far b/c he really is good and doesn’t even have to try!

    Crystal: amazing voice but her personality might hurt her. She could just be overwhelmed or just the mellow person that doesn’t freak out or show what she is feeling. It doesn’t look like she cares either way (although I’m sure she does) but america likes a kelly clarkson…and a personality can go far.

  18. Lindsay says:

    Kyle = AWESOME. Your comparison to Bill Rafferty was completely dead on and your fortune cookie Kara was hilarious. However, I’m a proud Tulsan and you almost soiled yourself on Fantasmagoria? I’m going to need your man card back. Bell’s closed down a few years ago :-( . Team Lee Dewyze.

  19. kyle says:

    Lindsay, Chili Pepper Plunge, Zingo, Wildcat; such great memories. When it closed down, I bought a Big Red, went to the front gate, drank half of it and poured the rest of the ashes of my fallen compadre. And burned my man card with everything else. How about Big Splash?

  20. Related…

    [...]just beneath, are numerous totally not related sites to ours, however, they are surely worth going over[...]…


Leave a Reply