Hall of Fame: Another Time

It’s been a long time since I inducted another class into the IHGB Hall of Fame. This group features men who managed to make my heart melt while they were brooding in period costumes. So much can be left unsaid when a kilt is involved, am I right?

Jamie Fraser
Jamie Fraser

I’m going to give you a moment to keep staring at his face. That chin is just one of the reasons James Alexander Malcolm MacKenzie Fraser made the Hall of Fame. The main reason he kicks off this list is his unflinching love and protection of Claire. When she fell (through time) into his life, the world no longer spun on its axis—it revolved around her. There is a deep passion between them, but equal respect. She is his match. Some call that a fairytale. I call it hope.

And real men wear kilts. That’s a fact. But it’s sort of weird if you’re not Scottish. Or attending a Scottish wedding or Halloween party. Keep that in mind.

Mr. Darcy
Mark Darcy
I’m definitely not that chick in the Austenland book/movie, but I certainly have been enamored with Mr. Darcy for multiple decades. When I read Pride & Prejudice, I didn’t really comprehend his desperate need for Elizabeth until I watched the double VHS tape, block-out-a-weekend, mini-series.

I understand there are purist out there who think the Keira Knightley version is abominable compared to BBC version. I concede that Colin Firth is the Darcy of all Darcys, but you have to admit that this is pretty romantic:

Matthew Crawley
Matthew Crawley

COUSIN MATTHEW! Those eyes. That smile. Those eyes. Only Matthew Crawley could tame Lady Mary. Downton Abbey hasn’t been the same since he’s been gone, or since that hot Turkish guy died. Can I get an amen?

Now it’s your turn. Who are the men from “the days of yore” who I may have missed? I’d love to research your suggestions. TRUST ME.

Comments

30 Comments on "Hall of Fame: Another Time"

avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest
Kristin
Kristin

I KNEW before I clicked that I would see Matthew Crawley! I think you should research the oldie-but-goodie, Gilbert Blythe. Sometimes he looks kind of young, but when he DOESN’T, he is hall-of-fame material, I think.

Abby
Abby

Sad news: Jonathan Crombie, the man who played Gilbert, died this week at age 48 of a brain aneurism. 🙁 🙁

Maria P
Maria P

Sidney Chambers played by James Norton on ‘Grantchester’ – it’s a British show, takes place in the 50’s that was playing on PBS – holy cheekbones! Inspector Jack Robinson played by Nathan Page on ‘Miss Fishers Murder Mysteries’- Australian show that takes place in the 20’s also playing on PBS. – deep voice, Australian accent, nuff said!

karen
karen

This is going back over 30 years. A Masterpiece Theater production of A Town Like Alice by Neville Shute. A WW2 love story starring a young Australian Bryon Brown. One of the greatest love stories of all times and he was amazing

Lorraine
Lorraine

Henry Cahill was pretty delicious as Charles Brandon in the Tudors.

Lorraine
Lorraine

That should be Cavill Stupid auto-correct. :o(

Quilting Hottie

I can never have need to rejoice more than I do that you have discovered the joy of Outlander. Jamie will forever and always be number one.

That said, I second Henry Cahill in the Tudors and add Jonathan Rhys Myers or however you spell his name who played a very non-historically accurate hotter than hell Henry VIII.

Also Patrick Swayze as Orry Main in North and South.

Lori
Lori

As a P&P fanatic, I need to point out that his name is actually Fitzwilliam Darcy. Mark Darcy is his alter-ego in Bridget Jones’s Diary. But you’re right that he’s the best Darcy of all time.

I also second Gilbert Blythe above!

Lori
Lori

And Daniel Day-Lewis in Last of the Mohicans should be on this list.

ChrisP
ChrisP

Or Daniel Day-Lewis in ANYTHING!

Nicole
Nicole

I submit Ben Barnes who played Sam Adams in the mini-series Sons of Liberty. I agree that Henry Cavill in The Tudors was smokin’. AND this may be wrong, but Diogo Morgado playing Jesus in Son of God was distractingly handsome! It was hard to concentrate…I’m just saying.

Susan
Susan

Michael Landon on Little on the Prairie!

Abby
Abby

Thank you very much for including Matthew Macfayden Mr. Darcy! I freaking love the 2005 version. The other day I had a conversation with my husband:

Me: Oh my gosh I turned in 5 stories today. My brain is dead. DEAD. What’s my name again?
Zach: Pearl. Because it’s Tuesday.

He was referring to the above scene. Not exact but the sentiment was so sweet that it made my day. Thank goodness for a husband that loves and appreciates Pride & Prejudice!

Other period film hotties: The pastor in the movie Christy (such an old movie):
http://www.imdb.com/media/rm927911168/nm0000871?ref_=nmmi_mi_all_pbl_25

Christian Bale in Little Women (another oldie)

James McAvoy in…. anything… That Jane Austen movie with Anne Hathaway, Atonement, etc.

Lorraine
Lorraine

Forgot all about Christian Bale in Little Women. Good call.

Katie
Katie

Yes, yes, yes to Christian Bale in Little Women!! The scene when he declares his love for Jo!

Lincee

AHHH! Christian Bale in Little Women… YES YES !

Barb
Barb

Nearly a perfect list! I would only add Skeet Ulrich playing Ray Singleton in “The Magic of Ordinary Days”.

Lincee

No clue. Googling now. Thank you Barb.

Patti

1. Richard Amitage as John Thornton in the BBC “North and South.”

2. Jeremy Northam as Mr. Knightley in the Gwyneth Paltrow “Emma.”

3. Jonny Lee Miller in the BBC “Emma.”

4. Michael Fassbender as Mr. Rochester in 2011 “Jane Eyre.”

Lincee

SO MANY MEN. SO LITTLE TIME. I’m on it Patti.

Lorraine
Lorraine

Yes! Michael Fassenbender in Jane Eyre. I think he did a great job as Mr. Rochester. Good Call on Jeremy Northam as Mr. Knightly.

Patti

Oh! And Matthew MacFadyen in the BBC “Little Dorrit.”

Lorraine
Lorraine

Richard Madden did a couple of things that I think qualify him for this Hall of Fame. He was in Klondike which is set during the Klondike Gold Rush. Do yourself a favor, and Google images for Richard Madden in Klondike.

wpDiscuz