Bless Tim’s sweet megawatt smile for not being in the bottom three last night. Oh the power of the tweeny-bopper texting skills.
Guest blogger Kyle talks about the “shocking” results show. Let us hear your thoughts in the comments section!
* * *
That’s it. Now I’m just making stuff up.
Seriously. That is how I feel about this season. I told Lincee today that it really is the Battle of the Mediocre. I have been trying to explain it more and more to people, but I can not put it into words.
That is…until something happened to me this morning. Let’s enter Kyle’s World for a second:
I was driving and listening to Sports Talk Radio when the host said, “Ok, we have been talking about baseball for a while. Let’s talk about College Football for a second, just to keep myself sane.”
And then, like an Adam Lambert screech, it hit me and almost knocked me unconscious. This season to me is like the OU/TEXAS game played every year in October. Now, I know all of you reading this are saying, “But Kyle, you love OSU with all your heart and despise OU and Texas!” If you said or thought this, well then pat your precious little head because you are right.
(ASIDE: I one time told a girl I was dating that if OSU sports was a person, I would cheat on her with that fake person.)
Let the record show that I have NEVER missed and OU/TEXAS game, and have attended about eight of the show downs in person. I can not imagine myself missing the game. The reason is simple. I LOVE college football. I will watch any game that is on TV because it is simply entertaining and awesome. However, I typically don’t root for anyone. In fact, if by some freak act of God, the game ended and they both lost? I would be so happy and loving every minute of it.
This is how I feel about Idol this year. I watch it because I like the show, I like singing. I enjoy the competition. But honestly, I don’t care about who wins. Nor am I rooting for anyone. Sure I like Lee and Crystal is doing great…which is similar to the TX/OU game last year. Sam Bradford and Colt McCoy were fun to watch and I liked them, but I wasn’t freakishly following them and addicted to their every move like I was Zac Robinson or Kris Allen (which I am sure is a shock to you all.)
My point? I will watch it to the end, but I am not invested at all.
So this is where I am. Stuck in some limbo Idol universe, not caring if I wait a day to watch the show. Watching it with one eye on the TV, and the other playing Words with Friends, trying to make sense out of my seven letters, which include AEIAOUU (honestly what my letters are in one of the games.) I tell you all this because I want to be honest with you. Because you know what? Every good relationship is built on honesty. And I feel like we are in a relationship. Stick with me friends, I will continue to bring you my random thoughts, pulled straight out of my head, most of the time making no sense at all. If you remember the old cartoon Bobby’s World, I want to bring you into Kyle’s World. It is a fun, sometimes scary, awkward place that will leave you wondering what the heck just happened. Saddle up partner. Let’s go.
This season’s theme is “Let’s Pull Out All The Stops and Try Anything Possible to Not Lose the Fans Who are Watching Now.”
They start the show in the control room. Again, it is just something new because people are fading.
Here’s how I envision that meeting going:
Randy sits at the table, staring off into space. He’s struggling to mentally name all the people he has produced a record with, wishing he would have bailed on the show two years ago, but then realizing if that happened, he would have absolutely no income at all.
Ellen listening to everything everyone is saying, but only because she wants to interject with a joke whenever she can.
Kara doodles on her napkin from lunch, drawing CJ + KD with a heart around it.
Ryan realizing he needs this gig, because without it, he really just hosts a TV show not many people watch with a weekly radio gig on the side.
Simon in his V-neck shirt, twirling his chest hair (because let’s face it—he checked out before the show started.) He finally pipes up and says with his best British accent, “We need to do something new. Let’s show the control room. Let’s have awkward interviews after the performances and uncomfortable scenes of the green room. Why don’t we invite mentors who make ABSOLUTELY no sense? Let’s place people in the crowd that BOO everything I say and have more fighting among the judges while ignoring the contestant on the stage.”
KARA SIDEBAR:
I have told you all before that I skip her every week. She drives me crazy, and I end up yelling at the screen. It is just healthier for everyone if I fast forward her comments. I know she wrote like 1 million songs and now has the ability to sign people to a deal, which is scary, but I can not stand her. I can recognize talent. I know the Coen Brothers make good movies, right? The majority of their work personally puts me to sleep, but there are about three that I really like. I know they have amazing talent and I respect them. Most of the time however, they are not for me.
Kara has none of that for me. I never watch and think, “Ok! You were actually right that time.” Her mouth opens and all I see are bugs coming out, much like John Coffee shot out in The Green Mile.
It was smart for the Idol Machine to re-visit Beatles week. The past couple of years, this category has been very successful. It was nice of McCartney to stop by for a quick “how ya doing?” And I totally expected Ryan to say, “Introducing our guest mentor—Justin Beiber.”
No. They wouldn’t do that. Surely. They would choose a mentor who made sense, right?
Ok, I am just coming out to say it. I heard three times today that Adam Lambert was going to be the mentor next week. And each time, I told the person they were drunk and/or dumb and convinced myself that somehow they were wrong. Ryan, however, ruined my night. Are you kidding me? Why would they have him at all? He has only been an artist for a year. He has not been in the spotlight long enough or had enough experience to tell the contestants what to do. I know some of you will comment and probably say one of two things:
1. Adam has been on that stage and he knows what they are going through.
2. Kyle, if Kris Allen were there, you would be dressing up for the show like you were taking him to a nice bistro for dinner.
To the number ones: I GET IT. He has been there before, but he is not going to be able to tell them what they are doing wrong. A year ago, he was in their same shoes. How can he now mentor them? I could totally be wrong and eat my words. If I am, I will admit it. I promise I will not be bias.
To the number twos: If Kris was on, I would feel the same way. But say it in a MUCH nicer way. How can you say anything mean to this presh face?

Ok, let’s look at the performances.
AARON
I did like how the other contestants told the audience dirt on the performers. I think it really showed how close they were, and tugged on some heart strings. Aaron as Yoda was a little random and Siobhan talking like Yoda scared me. She made me miss a little bit of the interview because I ran to turn the lights on. Like Kevin McCallister, I was home alone.

He sang “Long, Winding Road” wearing some sort of chef’s smock. It was a good vocal performance, but a boring one. There were a couple of times I almost changed the channel because I forgot I was watching it. He has a good voice when he stays in his little vocal box. He will not be able to sing if they take him out, but in the box, he is great. Just young and has some maturing to do.
And when did the show turn into WWF Raw? With the fans booing and screaming, I totally expect CoCoBware to come flying off the turnbuckle, knocking Simon unconscious.
KATIE
Let’s pimp Katie out a bit more. Is it fair to have her bribe her fans by saying whoever votes the most will get a Prom date? She sang “Let It Be.” I feel that season seven’s Brooke White’s version was amazingly better and have a tendency to compare all vocals to hers.
It was an okay performance. Just like every other week with her. It sounds like her voice is stuck. I keep waiting for her hit these notes and just go off, but it doesn’t. It just kind of stays in this one place. It is a decent place, but never does what you kind of think it will do. The judges liked it and said she will be back next week. I had to rewind, because I am pretty sure I saw Kara sing. Is there anything more embarrassing for a person to do? It reminds me of the Bikini Model’s audition last year when Kara belted out. Reason number 341,763 why she bugs me.
How about Ryan saying, “Well Katie. You have grown physically.” Can you legally say that without getting arrested? Sometimes he speaks and I am shocked. And it takes a lot to shock me. It reminded me of the time when Kellie Pickler had a guest performance sometime in the last two years. He said, “So. Did you buy ANYTHING new with your money?” Totally hinting at Ms. Pickler’s new boobs. Oh, sweet Ryan.
ANDREW
See? He has personality! He just can’t show it when he is on stage. But I think that was good for America to see him cracking the other players up. He sang “Can’t Buy Me Love.” I didn’t hate it. I and actually liked the arrangement, unlike Simon. I thought it was original. It wasn’t the best ever, but it was entertaining enough to watch. It was kind of cheesy though. I do like that he shows his voice. Unlike some of the other contestants, he does not hide behind his guitar. He belts it out and sings.
BIG MIKE
The first thing I will say is this: Was he really part of a group called the Lynch Mob growing up? Does anyone else think there is something wrong with that? I will stop there, so as to not get in trouble.
It was not that good of a performance. He was all over the place. He didn’t show his vocals very well and had no identity at all. At that moment, I put him straight into the bottom three and was scared he may go home. It was just strange. Randy said some parts worked. Which parts? It all sounded pretty bad.
About four times during one show, the judges go into their panel debate, totally ignoring the contestant. It is strange and a bit embarrassing. That is why I like the shows that are short, because then they do not have enough time for nonsense fighting.
CRYSTAL
Mama Sox sang “Come Together.” The Ricola guy bowing the fog horn made it seem like they were recording at the near the Wharf, but I liked it. This week, she was different. She has not sounded like this yet, and I liked it. She is very versatile. I like that. She has great potential and I hope she keeps showing us her range week after week. I feel like for a while she was stuck in a rut. It was a good rut, but still a rut. She has shown us that she can sing a lot of different types of songs and can sound really good no matter what she chooses. Randy and Simon both liked it. When did Randy become a member of a church congregation? Listen to him when Simon talks. (Umm huh. Yeah. Praise Jesus.)
TIM
Mr. Teeth and Hair sang “All my Lovin.” Like Randy said, it was a good Tim performance. He is in his own category and you have to judge him like that. He is kind of a strange performer. He is awkward to look at when he sings and most of the time he looks like he does not know what to do with himself. I believe he is still in the running because of the ridiculous site www.votefortheworst.com. For me, this site screams GET A LIFE!. Really? You have nothing better to do than watch a show you obviously don’t like and spend time voting to sabotage potential winners? I predict he will be in the bottom three off and on and should be voted off in the nest couple of weeks.
CASEY
I liked the name Lee gave to Casey…Trevor. Drake just screams good looking lead in romance novel. The one thing they missed in the interview was having Kara talk, which actually was possibly a good thing. She would have wet herself, cried and not been able to continue. He sang “Jealous Guy.” I actually liked it. It was the first time you could really hear his voice and he didn’t hide behind the band. If he is going to make it far, he needs to do more performances like this one. It was simple and showed off his voice. With that performance, he probably put himself into the bottom four.
SIOBHAN
News Flash: she is amazingly weird. But I like that Siobhan acknowledges that she is weird. Embrace it and run with it. You have to commend her for that. According to her dress, she is playing the part of town wench at the Renaissance Festival. Glad she could make it for the show. She sang “Across the Universe” and it had the same feeling as when Adam sang “Tracks of my Tears” last year—just not as good. She kind of slowed it down a little bit. Randy said she had the best possibility to be an artist and Simon said she had a disastrous week last week and came back strong this week.
I am glad Earl could have his 15 minutes of fame by yelling at Simon and getting up on stage to hug Siobhan.
LEE
Mr. Worrywart. You can totally see that in him. He can not keep thinking like that or he will go home. He needs to grow a pair and realize he is a good singer. It happened last year for Kris and the year before with Archuletta. And they had great success. I love the relationship with him and Andrew and how Crystal thinks they should get married. That is healthy for a guy to have in his life. James, one of my best friends, is like that for me. His wife told us that she is glad they got married, because too much longer and he and I would have just moved in together and been fine the rest of our lives.
He sang “Hey Jude.” I’m not sure that was the best song to sing. It is more of a stadium song, but he did great with it. It was not his best, but he did his best with what he had.
SIDEBAR: BUY LEE DEWYZE SINGING “BEAST OF BURDEN” ON ITUNES. LIVE, I DIDNT LOVE IT. BUT RECORDED…IT MAY BE THE BEST OF THE YEAR.
Unlike Simon, I loved the bagpipe. Like Crystal’s, it added something that you don’t normally see. It is funny that the two best performers threw in something unique. That shows they talent they have.
With that said, I’m a little worried about in the show. Even though I like Crystal and Lee, they are not jump out of the screen, knock you out of your seat awesome. I could totally see one of them being in the bottom three in the next couple of weeks. Do I want them there? No way. Do they deserve to be there? No way. However, I think that people are fading out of the show. Your casual fan who watches for good music are turning it off and not voting.
RESULTS SHOW
Not a whole lot to talk about here.
Kara is dressed up as the Princess of Persia. They lip sync another performance, which is absolute trash. I have said it before—it is kind of disrespectful. I remember when they used to sing. Oh those days were awesome and so much fun to watch.
Ryan has given up with creative ways to eliminate people. He is reaching now. It will be a matter of time before he asks Katie and Crystal to head up to the third row and stand on their heads while he makes Michael and Andrew sprawl head first down the stairs. Poor little Aaron will be forced to hold his breath in a tank of water. Hey! If you are a Libra…you are SAFE!
Here’s a question for you. Why is it that when some people perform, they announce themselves and say their name as part of the song? Sure, I was glad Jason D. did that because I had no idea who he was. Otherwise, I think it is so random.
I loved that they brought out Archie out to show everyone what a good performance looks like. Nay. What a GREAT performance looks like! He did that same piece BEFORE the top 12. That was talent. This is what I have been saying is missing this year. And thank you Ryan for an awkward DA exit. He looked confused and kind of waved and sauntered off.
Rhianna? What the heck was that performance? Was she attempting to one-up Michelle Pfeiffer for tightest outfit in the world? Did she ever really sing? What was she doing on the guitar? Because I know she was not playing it. Did anyone else notice the construction workin’ girl on the crow’s nest grinding her stomach? WHAT? It seems like she is not quite sure what sort of performer she was.
Poor Michael. He got voted off. I said to myself, there is only one song he can sing for him to be saved. He did it and hit it out of the park. I’m glad the judges saved him. The ball is in his court right now. If he messes up his second chance, he deserves to go home. I believe that he will take advantage of it and do great in the following weeks.
GLEE NEXT WEEK. That’s right people! Set your DVRs for 8:28 and watch the best show on TV right now. It is so much talent and so much fun to watch. I won’t get on my soap box for that, but man it is so good.

Who do you think are the next to leave the show? Who do you think will be the bottom three? Who do you want to see as a guest mentor? Do you ever vote? What about Glee? Hate it? Love it? Talk to me Goose. Let’s hear you and your opinions. And as always, thanks for reading.